Representative · D-NY
The bill increases consumer and health-system protection against extreme price spikes in declared shortages by clarifying authority and raising penalties, but it risks heavy penalties, legal uncertainty, and unintended supply-side responses that could hurt small businesses and availability of goods.
Low-income households and other consumers are less likely to face extreme price spikes for food, medicines, fuel, and emergency supplies during declared acute shortages.
Hospitals and emergency responders can obtain essential medical supplies and fuel more affordably during acute shortages, supporting continuity of care and emergency response.
Clearer criminal penalties and large fines increase deterrence against intentional price-gouging and hoarding during crises.
Small sellers face severe civil and criminal penalties (including fines up to 300% of violating revenue and possible criminal exposure), which could raise compliance costs, drive small businesses out of markets, or criminalize marginal mistakes.
Businesses may preemptively raise prices or restrict supply to avoid liability, potentially shrinking availability of goods during emergencies and harming both consumers and critical responders.
Ambiguous language (e.g., 'grossly exceed', discretionary exceptions, and broadly interpreted 'willful' standards) creates enforcement uncertainty and a high risk of litigation, imposing costs on businesses, state governments, and taxpayers.
Based on analysis of 2 sections of legislative text.
Amends the Defense Production Act to ban selling or hoarding designated scarce or critical goods at grossly above-market or "unfairly excessive" prices and adds criminal penalties tied to violation revenue.
Official title: To amend the Defense Production Act of 1950 to provide for stricter prohibitions on price gouging of certain materials, and for other purposes.
Introduced July 23, 2025 by Josh Riley · Last progress July 23, 2025
Adds an explicit federal ban on selling designated scarce or critical goods at "grossly" above market prices or at an "unfairly excessive price," and expands hoarding prohibitions to cover critical goods in an "acute shortage." The bill defines key terms (including presumptive 10% threshold for "unfairly excessive price") and creates criminal penalties for willful violations, including fines equal to the greater of $20,000 or 300% of revenue from the violation. The change is implemented by amending the Defense Production Act authority that governs allocation and anti-hoarding rules, replacing an older resale-price provision with a clearer price-gouging standard and new definitions to broaden enforcement during shortages of critical goods.