((a)) ** Requirement of registration** Except as provided by this subchapter, no person in any State may distribute or sell to any person any pesticide that is not registered under this subchapter. To the extent necessary to prevent unreasonable adverse effects on the environment, the Administrator may by regulation limit the distribution, sale, or use in any State of any pesticide that is not registered under this subchapter and that is not the subject of an experimental use permit under or an emergency exemption under .section 136c of this titlesection 136p of this title

((b)) ** Exemptions** A pesticide which is not registered with the Administrator may be transferred if—

((1)) the transfer is from one registered establishment to another registered establishment operated by the same producer solely for packaging at the second establishment or for use as a constituent part of another pesticide produced at the second establishment; or

((2)) the transfer is pursuant to and in accordance with the requirements of an experimental use permit.

((c)) ** Procedure for registration**

((1)) ** Statement required** Each applicant for registration of a pesticide shall file with the Administrator a statement which includes—

((A)) the name and address of the applicant and of any other person whose name will appear on the labeling;

((B)) the name of the pesticide;

((C)) a complete copy of the labeling of the pesticide, a statement of all claims to be made for it, and any directions for its use;

((D)) the complete formula of the pesticide;

((E)) a request that the pesticide be classified for general use or for restricted use, or for both; and

((F)) except as otherwise provided in paragraph (2)(D), if requested by the Administrator, a full description of the tests made and the results thereof upon which the claims are based, or alternatively a citation to data that appear in the public literature or that previously had been submitted to the Administrator and that the Administrator may consider in accordance with the following provisions:

((i)) With respect to pesticides containing active ingredients that are initially registered under this subchapter after , data submitted to support the application for the original registration of the pesticide, or an application for an amendment adding any new use to the registration and that pertains solely to such new use, shall not, without the written permission of the original data submitter, be considered by the Administrator to support an application by another person during a period of ten years following the date the Administrator first registers the pesticide, except that such permission shall not be required in the case of defensive data.

((ii)) The period of exclusive data use provided under clause (i) shall be extended 1 additional year for each 3 minor uses registered after , and within 7 years of the commencement of the exclusive use period, up to a total of 3 additional years for all minor uses registered by the Administrator if the Administrator, in consultation with the Secretary of Agriculture, determines that, based on information provided by an applicant for registration or a registrant, that—

((I)) there are insufficient efficacious alternative registered pesticides available for the use;

((II)) the alternatives to the minor use pesticide pose greater risks to the environment or human health;

((III)) the minor use pesticide plays or will play a significant part in managing pest resistance; or

((IV)) the minor use pesticide plays or will play a significant part in an integrated pest management program.

((iii)) Except as otherwise provided in clause (i), with respect to data submitted after , by an applicant or registrant to support an application for registration, experimental use permit, or amendment adding a new use to an existing registration, to support or maintain in effect an existing registration, or for reregistration, the Administrator may, without the permission of the original data submitter, consider any such item of data in support of an application by any other person (hereinafter in this subparagraph referred to as the “applicant”) within the fifteen-year period following the date the data were originally submitted only if the applicant has made an offer to compensate the original data submitter and submitted such offer to the Administrator accompanied by evidence of delivery to the original data submitter of the offer. The terms and amount of compensation may be fixed by agreement between the original data submitter and the applicant, or, failing such agreement, binding arbitration under this subparagraph. If, at the end of ninety days after the date of delivery to the original data submitter of the offer to compensate, the original data submitter and the applicant have neither agreed on the amount and terms of compensation nor on a procedure for reaching an agreement on the amount and terms of compensation, either person may initiate binding arbitration proceedings by requesting the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service to appoint an arbitrator from the roster of arbitrators maintained by such Service. The procedure and rules of the Service shall be applicable to the selection of such arbitrator and to such arbitration proceedings, and the findings and determination of the arbitrator shall be final and conclusive, and no official or court of the United States shall have power or jurisdiction to review any such findings and determination, except for fraud, misrepresentation, or other misconduct by one of the parties to the arbitration or the arbitrator where there is a verified complaint with supporting affidavits attesting to specific instances of such fraud, misrepresentation, or other misconduct. The parties to the arbitration shall share equally in the payment of the fee and expenses of the arbitrator. If the Administrator determines that an original data submitter has failed to participate in a procedure for reaching an agreement or in an arbitration proceeding as required by this subparagraph, or failed to comply with the terms of an agreement or arbitration decision concerning compensation under this subparagraph, the original data submitter shall forfeit the right to compensation for the use of the data in support of the application. Notwithstanding any other provision of this subchapter, if the Administrator determines that an applicant has failed to participate in a procedure for reaching an agreement or in an arbitration proceeding as required by this subparagraph, or failed to comply with the terms of an agreement or arbitration decision concerning compensation under this subparagraph, the Administrator shall deny the application or cancel the registration of the pesticide in support of which the data were used without further hearing. Before the Administrator takes action under either of the preceding two sentences, the Administrator shall furnish to the affected person, by certified mail, notice of intent to take action and allow fifteen days from the date of delivery of the notice for the affected person to respond. If a registration is denied or canceled under this subparagraph, the Administrator may make such order as the Administrator deems appropriate concerning the continued sale and use of existing stocks of such pesticide. Registration action by the Administrator shall not be delayed pending the fixing of compensation.

((iv)) After expiration of any period of exclusive use and any period for which compensation is required for the use of an item of data under clauses (i), (ii), and (iii), the Administrator may consider such item of data in support of an application by any other applicant without the permission of the original data submitter and without an offer having been received to compensate the original data submitter for the use of such item of data.

((v)) The period of exclusive use provided under clause (ii) shall not take effect until 1 year after , except where an applicant or registrant is applying for the registration of a pesticide containing an active ingredient not previously registered.

((vi)) With respect to data submitted after , by an applicant or registrant to support an amendment adding a new use to an existing registration that does not retain any period of exclusive use, if such data relates solely to a minor use of a pesticide, such data shall not, without the written permission of the original data submitter, be considered by the Administrator to support an application for a minor use by another person during the period of 10 years following the date of submission of such data. The applicant or registrant at the time the new minor use is requested shall notify the Administrator that to the best of their knowledge the exclusive use period for the pesticide has expired and that the data pertaining solely to the minor use of a pesticide is eligible for the provisions of this paragraph. If the minor use registration which is supported by data submitted pursuant to this subsection is voluntarily canceled or if such data are subsequently used to support a nonminor use, the data shall no longer be subject to the exclusive use provisions of this clause but shall instead be considered by the Administrator in accordance with the provisions of clause (i), as appropriate.

((G)) If the applicant is requesting that the registration or amendment to the registration of a pesticide be expedited, an explanation of the basis for the request must be submitted, in accordance with paragraph (10) of this subsection.

((2)) ** Data in support of registration**

((A)) ** In general** The Administrator shall publish guidelines specifying the kinds of information which will be required to support the registration of a pesticide and shall revise such guidelines from time to time. If thereafter the Administrator requires any additional kind of information under subparagraph (B) of this paragraph, the Administrator shall permit sufficient time for applicants to obtain such additional information. The Administrator, in establishing standards for data requirements for the registration of pesticides with respect to minor uses, shall make such standards commensurate with the anticipated extent of use, pattern of use, the public health and agricultural need for such minor use, and the level and degree of potential beneficial or adverse effects on man and the environment. The Administrator shall not require a person to submit, in relation to a registration or reregistration of a pesticide for minor agricultural use under this subchapter, any field residue data from a geographic area where the pesticide will not be registered for such use. In the development of these standards, the Administrator shall consider the economic factors of potential national volume of use, extent of distribution, and the impact of the cost of meeting the requirements on the incentives for any potential registrant to undertake the development of the required data. Except as provided by , within 30 days after the Administrator registers a pesticide under this subchapter the Administrator shall make available to the public the data called for in the registration statement together with such other scientific information as the Administrator deems relevant to the Administrator’s decision.section 136h of this title

((B)) ** Additional data**

((i)) If the Administrator determines that additional data are required to maintain in effect an existing registration of a pesticide, the Administrator shall notify all existing registrants of the pesticide to which the determination relates and provide a list of such registrants to any interested person.

((ii)) Each registrant of such pesticide shall provide evidence within ninety days after receipt of notification that it is taking appropriate steps to secure the additional data that are required. Two or more registrants may agree to develop jointly, or to share in the cost of developing, such data if they agree and advise the Administrator of their intent within ninety days after notification. Any registrant who agrees to share in the cost of producing the data shall be entitled to examine and rely upon such data in support of maintenance of such registration. The Administrator shall issue a notice of intent to suspend the registration of a pesticide in accordance with the procedures prescribed by clause (iv) if a registrant fails to comply with this clause.

((iii)) If, at the end of sixty days after advising the Administrator of their agreement to develop jointly, or share in the cost of developing, data, the registrants have not further agreed on the terms of the data development arrangement or on a procedure for reaching such agreement, any of such registrants may initiate binding arbitration proceedings by requesting the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service to appoint an arbitrator from the roster of arbitrators maintained by such Service. The procedure and rules of the Service shall be applicable to the selection of such arbitrator and to such arbitration proceedings, and the findings and determination of the arbitrator shall be final and conclusive, and no official or court of the United States shall have power or jurisdiction to review any such findings and determination, except for fraud, misrepresentation, or other misconduct by one of the parties to the arbitration or the arbitrator where there is a verified complaint with supporting affidavits attesting to specific instances of such fraud, misrepresentation, or other misconduct. All parties to the arbitration shall share equally in the payment of the fee and expenses of the arbitrator. The Administrator shall issue a notice of intent to suspend the registration of a pesticide in accordance with the procedures prescribed by clause (iv) if a registrant fails to comply with this clause.

((iv)) Notwithstanding any other provision of this subchapter, if the Administrator determines that a registrant, within the time required by the Administrator, has failed to take appropriate steps to secure the data required under this subparagraph, to participate in a procedure for reaching agreement concerning a joint data development arrangement under this subparagraph or in an arbitration proceeding as required by this subparagraph, or to comply with the terms of an agreement or arbitration decision concerning a joint data development arrangement under this subparagraph, the Administrator may issue a notice of intent to suspend such registrant’s registration of the pesticide for which additional data is required. The Administrator may include in the notice of intent to suspend such provisions as the Administrator deems appropriate concerning the continued sale and use of existing stocks of such pesticide. Any suspension proposed under this subparagraph shall become final and effective at the end of thirty days from receipt by the registrant of the notice of intent to suspend, unless during that time a request for hearing is made by a person adversely affected by the notice or the registrant has satisfied the Administrator that the registrant has complied fully with the requirements that served as a basis for the notice of intent to suspend. If a hearing is requested, a hearing shall be conducted under . The only matters for resolution at that hearing shall be whether the registrant has failed to take the action that served as the basis for the notice of intent to suspend the registration of the pesticide for which additional data is required, and whether the Administrator’s determination with respect to the disposition of existing stocks is consistent with this subchapter. If a hearing is held, a decision after completion of such hearing shall be final. Notwithstanding any other provision of this subchapter, a hearing shall be held and a determination made within seventy-five days after receipt of a request for such hearing. Any registration suspended under this subparagraph shall be reinstated by the Administrator if the Administrator determines that the registrant has complied fully with the requirements that served as a basis for the suspension of the registration.

((v)) Any data submitted under this subparagraph shall be subject to the provisions of paragraph (1)(D). Whenever such data are submitted jointly by two or more registrants, an agent shall be agreed on at the time of the joint submission to handle any subsequent data compensation matters for the joint submitters of such data.

((vi)) Upon the request of a registrant the Administrator shall, in the case of a minor use, extend the deadline for the production of residue chemistry data under this subparagraph for data required solely to support that minor use until the final deadline for submission of data under for the other uses of the pesticide established as of , if—

((I)) the data to support other uses of the pesticide on a food are being provided;

((II)) the registrant, in submitting a request for such an extension, provides a schedule, including interim dates to measure progress, to assure that the data production will be completed before the expiration of the extension period;

((III)) the Administrator has determined that such extension will not significantly delay the Administrator’s schedule for issuing a reregistration eligibility determination required under ; and

((IV)) the Administrator has determined that based on existing data, such extension would not significantly increase the risk of any unreasonable adverse effect on the environment. If the Administrator grants an extension under this clause, the Administrator shall monitor the development of the data and shall ensure that the registrant is meeting the schedule for the production of the data. If the Administrator determines that the registrant is not meeting or has not met the schedule for the production of such data, the Administrator may proceed in accordance with clause (iv) regarding the continued registration of the affected products with the minor use and shall inform the public of such action. Notwithstanding the provisions of this clause, the Administrator may take action to modify or revoke the extension under this clause if the Administrator determines that the extension for the minor use may cause an unreasonable adverse effect on the environment. In such circumstance, the Administrator shall provide, in writing to the registrant, a notice revoking the extension of time for submission of data. Such data shall instead be due in accordance with the date established by the Administrator for the submission of the data.

((vii)) If the registrant does not commit to support a specific minor use of the pesticide, but is supporting and providing data in a timely and adequate fashion to support uses of the pesticide on a food, or if all uses of the pesticide are nonfood uses and the registrant does not commit to support a specific minor use of the pesticide but is supporting and providing data in a timely and adequate fashion to support other nonfood uses of the pesticide, the Administrator, at the written request of the registrant, shall not take any action pursuant to this clause in regard to such unsupported minor use until the final deadline established as of , for the submission of data under for the supported uses identified pursuant to this clause unless the Administrator determines that the absence of the data is significant enough to cause human health or environmental concerns. On the basis of such determination, the Administrator may refuse the request for extension by the registrant. Upon receipt of the request from the registrant, the Administrator shall publish in the Federal Register a notice of the receipt of the request and the effective date upon which the uses not being supported will be voluntarily deleted from the registration pursuant to . If the Administrator grants an extension under this clause, the Administrator shall monitor the development of the data for the uses being supported and shall ensure that the registrant is meeting the schedule for the production of such data. If the Administrator determines that the registrant is not meeting or has not met the schedule for the production of such data, the Administrator may proceed in accordance with clause (iv) of this subparagraph regarding the continued registration of the affected products with the minor and other uses and shall inform the public of such action in accordance with . Notwithstanding the provisions of this clause, the Administrator may deny, modify, or revoke the temporary extension under this subparagraph if the Administrator determines that the continuation of the minor use may cause an unreasonable adverse effect on the environment. In the event of modification or revocation, the Administrator shall provide, in writing, to the registrant a notice revoking the temporary extension and establish a new effective date by which the minor use shall be deleted from the registration.

((viii))

((I)) If data required to support registration of a pesticide under subparagraph (A) is requested by a Federal or State regulatory authority, the Administrator shall, to the extent practicable, coordinate data requirements, test protocols, timetables, and standards of review and reduce burdens and redundancy caused to the registrant by multiple requirements on the registrant.

((II)) The Administrator may enter into a cooperative agreement with a State to carry out subclause (I).

((III)) Not later than 1 year after , the Administrator shall develop a process to identify and assist in alleviating future disparities between Federal and State data requirements.

((C)) ** Simplified procedures** Within nine months after , the Administrator shall, by regulation, prescribe simplified procedures for the registration of pesticides, which shall include the provisions of subparagraph (D) of this paragraph.September 30, 19781978-09-30

((D)) ** Exemption** No applicant for registration of a pesticide who proposes to purchase a registered pesticide from another producer in order to formulate such purchased pesticide into the pesticide that is the subject of the application shall be required to—

((i)) submit or cite data pertaining to such purchased product; or

((ii)) offer to pay reasonable compensation otherwise required by paragraph (1)(D) of this subsection for the use of any such data.

((E)) ** Minor use waiver** In handling the registration of a pesticide for a minor use, the Administrator may waive otherwise applicable data requirements if the Administrator determines that the absence of such data will not prevent the Administrator from determining—

((i)) the incremental risk presented by the minor use of the pesticide; and

((ii)) that such risk, if any, would not be an unreasonable adverse effect on the environment.

((3)) ** Application**

((A)) ** In general** The Administrator shall review the data after receipt of the application and shall, as expeditiously as possible, either register the pesticide in accordance with paragraph (5), or notify the applicant of the Administrator’s determination that it does not comply with the provisions of the subchapter in accordance with paragraph (6).

((B)) ** Identical or substantially similar**

((i)) The Administrator shall, as expeditiously as possible, review and act on any application received by the Administrator that—

((I)) proposes the initial or amended registration of an end-use pesticide that, if registered as proposed, would be identical or substantially similar in composition and labeling to a currently-registered pesticide identified in the application, or that would differ in composition and labeling from such currently-registered pesticide only in ways that would not significantly increase the risk of unreasonable adverse effects on the environment; or

((II)) proposes an amendment to the registration of a registered pesticide that does not require scientific review of data.

((ii)) In expediting the review of an application for an action described in clause (i), the Administrator shall—

((I)) review the application in accordance with and, if the application is found to be incomplete, reject the application;

((II)) not later than the applicable decision review time established pursuant to , or, if no review time is established, not later than 90 days after receiving a complete application, notify the registrant if the application has been granted or denied; and

((III)) if the application is denied, notify the registrant in writing of the specific reasons for the denial of the application.

((C)) ** Minor use registration**

((i)) The Administrator shall, as expeditiously as possible, review and act on any complete application—

((I)) that proposes the initial registration of a new pesticide active ingredient if the active ingredient is proposed to be registered solely for minor uses, or proposes a registration amendment solely for minor uses to an existing registration; or

((II)) for a registration or a registration amendment that proposes significant minor uses.

((ii)) For the purposes of clause (i)—

((I)) the term “as expeditiously as possible” means that the Administrator shall, to the greatest extent practicable, complete a review and evaluation of all data, submitted with a complete application, within 12 months after the submission of the complete application, and the failure of the Administrator to complete such a review and evaluation under clause (i) shall not be subject to judicial review; and

((II)) the term “significant minor uses” means 3 or more minor uses proposed for every nonminor use, a minor use that would, in the judgment of the Administrator, serve as a replacement for any use which has been canceled in the 5 years preceding the receipt of the application, or a minor use that in the opinion of the Administrator would avoid the reissuance of an emergency exemption under for that minor use.

((D)) ** Adequate time for submission of minor use data** If a registrant makes a request for a minor use waiver, regarding data required by the Administrator, pursuant to paragraph (2)(E), and if the Administrator denies in whole or in part such data waiver request, the registrant shall have a full-time period for providing such data. For purposes of this subparagraph, the term “full-time period” means the time period originally established by the Administrator for submission of such data, beginning with the date of receipt by the registrant of the Administrator’s notice of denial.

((4)) ** Notice of application** The Administrator shall publish in the Federal Register, promptly after receipt of the statement and other data required pursuant to paragraphs (1) and (2), a notice of each application for registration of any pesticide if it contains any new active ingredient or if it would entail a changed use pattern. The notice shall provide for a period of 30 days in which any Federal agency or any other interested person may comment.

((5)) ** Approval of registration** The Administrator shall register a pesticide if the Administrator determines that, when considered with any restrictions imposed under subsection (d)—

((A)) its composition is such as to warrant the proposed claims for it;

((B)) its labeling and other material required to be submitted comply with the requirements of this subchapter;

((C)) it will perform its intended function without unreasonable adverse effects on the environment; and

((D)) when used in accordance with widespread and commonly recognized practice it will not generally cause unreasonable adverse effects on the environment.

((6)) ** Denial of registration** If the Administrator determines that the requirements of paragraph (5) for registration are not satisfied, the Administrator shall notify the applicant for registration of the Administrator’s determination and of the Administrator’s reasons (including the factual basis) therefor, and that, unless the applicant corrects the conditions and notifies the Administrator thereof during the 30-day period beginning with the day after the date on which the applicant receives the notice, the Administrator may refuse to register the pesticide. Whenever the Administrator refuses to register a pesticide, the Administrator shall notify the applicant of the Administrator’s decision and of the Administrator’s reasons (including the factual basis) therefor. The Administrator shall promptly publish in the Federal Register notice of such denial of registration and the reasons therefor. Upon such notification, the applicant for registration or other interested person with the concurrence of the applicant shall have the same remedies as provided for in .section 136d of this title

((7)) ** Registration under special circumstances** Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph (5)—

((A)) The Administrator may conditionally register or amend the registration of a pesticide if the Administrator determines that (i) the pesticide and proposed use are identical or substantially similar to any currently registered pesticide and use thereof, or differ only in ways that would not significantly increase the risk of unreasonable adverse effects on the environment, and (ii) approving the registration or amendment in the manner proposed by the applicant would not significantly increase the risk of any unreasonable adverse effect on the environment. An applicant seeking conditional registration or amended registration under this subparagraph shall submit such data as would be required to obtain registration of a similar pesticide under paragraph (5). If the applicant is unable to submit an item of data because it has not yet been generated, the Administrator may register or amend the registration of the pesticide under such conditions as will require the submission of such data not later than the time such data are required to be submitted with respect to similar pesticides already registered under this subchapter.

((B)) The Administrator may conditionally amend the registration of a pesticide to permit additional uses of such pesticide notwithstanding that data concerning the pesticide may be insufficient to support an unconditional amendment, if the Administrator determines that (i) the applicant has submitted satisfactory data pertaining to the proposed additional use, and (ii) amending the registration in the manner proposed by the applicant would not significantly increase the risk of any unreasonable adverse effect on the environment. Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this subparagraph, no registration of a pesticide may be amended to permit an additional use of such pesticide if the Administrator has issued a notice stating that such pesticide, or any ingredient thereof, meets or exceeds risk criteria associated in whole or in part with human dietary exposure enumerated in regulations issued under this subchapter, and during the pendency of any risk-benefit evaluation initiated by such notice, if (I) the additional use of such pesticide involves a major food or feed crop, or (II) the additional use of such pesticide involves a minor food or feed crop and the Administrator determines, with the concurrence of the Secretary of Agriculture, there is available an effective alternative pesticide that does not meet or exceed such risk criteria. An applicant seeking amended registration under this subparagraph shall submit such data as would be required to obtain registration of a similar pesticide under paragraph (5). If the applicant is unable to submit an item of data (other than data pertaining to the proposed additional use) because it has not yet been generated, the Administrator may amend the registration under such conditions as will require the submission of such data not later than the time such data are required to be submitted with respect to similar pesticides already registered under this subchapter.

((C)) The Administrator may conditionally register a pesticide containing an active ingredient not contained in any currently registered pesticide for a period reasonably sufficient for the generation and submission of required data (which are lacking because a period reasonably sufficient for generation of the data has not elapsed since the Administrator first imposed the data requirement) on the condition that by the end of such period the Administrator receives such data and the data do not meet or exceed risk criteria enumerated in regulations issued under this subchapter, and on such other conditions as the Administrator may prescribe. A conditional registration under this subparagraph shall be granted only if the Administrator determines that use of the pesticide during such period will not cause any unreasonable adverse effect on the environment, and that use of the pesticide is in the public interest.

((8)) ** Interim administrative review** Notwithstanding any other provision of this subchapter, the Administrator may not initiate a public interim administrative review process to develop a risk-benefit evaluation of the ingredients of a pesticide or any of its uses prior to initiating a formal action to cancel, suspend, or deny registration of such pesticide, required under this subchapter, unless such interim administrative process is based on a validated test or other significant evidence raising prudent concerns of unreasonable adverse risk to man or to the environment. Notice of the definition of the terms “validated test” and “other significant evidence” as used herein shall be published by the Administrator in the Federal Register.

((9)) ** Labeling**

((A)) ** Additional statements** Subject to subparagraphs (B) and (C), it shall not be a violation of this subchapter for a registrant to modify the labeling of an antimicrobial pesticide product to include relevant information on product efficacy, product composition, container composition or design, or other characteristics that do not relate to any pesticidal claim or pesticidal activity.

((B)) ** Requirements** Proposed labeling information under subparagraph (A) shall not be false or misleading, shall not conflict with or detract from any statement required by law or the Administrator as a condition of registration, and shall be substantiated on the request of the Administrator.

((C)) ** Notification and disapproval**

((i)) ** Notification** A registration may be modified under subparagraph (A) if—

((I)) the registrant notifies the Administrator in writing not later than 60 days prior to distribution or sale of a product bearing the modified labeling; and

((II)) the Administrator does not disapprove of the modification under clause (ii).

((ii)) ** Disapproval** Not later than 30 days after receipt of a notification under clause (i), the Administrator may disapprove the modification by sending the registrant notification in writing stating that the proposed language is not acceptable and stating the reasons why the Administrator finds the proposed modification unacceptable.

((iii)) ** Restriction on sale** A registrant may not sell or distribute a product bearing a disapproved modification.

((iv)) ** Objection** A registrant may file an objection in writing to a disapproval under clause (ii) not later than 30 days after receipt of notification of the disapproval.

((v)) ** Final action** A decision by the Administrator following receipt and consideration of an objection filed under clause (iv) shall be considered a final agency action.

((D)) ** Use dilution** The label or labeling required under this subchapter for an antimicrobial pesticide that is or may be diluted for use may have a different statement of caution or protective measures for use of the recommended diluted solution of the pesticide than for use of a concentrate of the pesticide if the Administrator determines that—

((i)) adequate data have been submitted to support the statement proposed for the diluted solution uses; and

((ii)) the label or labeling provides adequate protection for exposure to the diluted solution of the pesticide.

((10)) ** Expedited registration of pesticides**

((A)) Not later than 1 year after , the Administrator shall, utilizing public comment, develop procedures and guidelines, and expedite the review of an application for registration of a pesticide or an amendment to a registration that satisfies such guidelines.

((B)) Any application for registration or an amendment, including biological and conventional pesticides, will be considered for expedited review under this paragraph. An application for registration or an amendment shall qualify for expedited review if use of the pesticide proposed by the application may reasonably be expected to accomplish 1 or more of the following:

((i)) Reduce the risks of pesticides to human health.

((ii)) Reduce the risks of pesticides to nontarget organisms.

((iii)) Reduce the potential for contamination of groundwater, surface water, or other valued environmental resources.

((iv)) Broaden the adoption of integrated pest management strategies, or make such strategies more available or more effective.

((C)) The Administrator, not later than 30 days after receipt of an application for expedited review, shall notify the applicant whether the application is complete. If it is found to be incomplete, the Administrator may either reject the request for expedited review or ask the applicant for additional information to satisfy the guidelines developed under subparagraph (A).

((11)) ** Interagency working group**

((A)) ** Definition of covered agency** In this paragraph, the term “covered agency” means any of the following:

((i)) The Department of Agriculture.

((ii)) The Department of Commerce.

((iii)) The Department of the Interior.

((iv)) The Council on Environmental Quality.

((v)) The Environmental Protection Agency.

((B)) ** Establishment** The Administrator shall establish an interagency working group, to be comprised of representatives from each covered agency, to provide recommendations regarding, and to implement a strategy for improving, the consultation process required under section 7 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 () for pesticide registration and registration review.16 U.S.C. 1536

((C)) ** Duties** The interagency working group established under subparagraph (B) shall—

((i)) analyze relevant Federal law (including regulations) and case law for purposes of providing an outline of the legal and regulatory framework for the consultation process referred to in that subparagraph, including—

((I)) requirements under this subchapter and the Endangered Species Act of 1973 ( et seq.);

((II)) Federal case law regarding the intersection of this subchapter and the Endangered Species Act of 1973 ( et seq.); and

((III)) Federal regulations relating to the pesticide consultation process;

((ii)) provide advice regarding methods of—

((I)) defining the scope of actions of the covered agencies that are subject to the consultation requirement referred to in subparagraph (B); and

((II)) properly identifying and classifying effects of actions of the covered agencies with respect to that consultation requirement;

((iii)) identify the obligations and limitations under Federal law of each covered agency for purposes of providing a legal and regulatory framework for developing the recommendations referred to in subparagraph (B);

((iv)) review practices for the consultation referred to in subparagraph (B) to identify problem areas, areas for improvement, and best practices for conducting that consultation among the covered agencies;

((v)) develop scientific and policy approaches to increase the accuracy and timeliness of the process for that consultation, in accordance with requirements of this subchapter and the Endangered Species Act of 1973 ( et seq.), including—

((I)) processes to efficiently share data and coordinate analyses among the Department of Agriculture, the Department of Commerce, the Department of the Interior, and the Environmental Protection Agency;

((II)) a streamlined process for identifying which actions require no consultation, informal consultation, or formal consultation;

((III)) an approach that will provide clarity with respect to what constitutes the best scientific and commercial data available in the fields of pesticide use and ecological risk assessment, pursuant to section 7(a)(2) of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (); and

((IV)) approaches that enable the Environmental Protection Agency to better assist the Department of the Interior and the Department of Commerce in carrying out obligations under that section in a timely and efficient manner; and

((vi)) propose and implement a strategy to implement approaches to consultations under the Endangered Species Act of 1973 ( et seq.) and document that strategy in a memorandum of understanding, revised regulations, or another appropriate format to promote durable cooperation among the covered agencies.

((D)) ** Reports**

((i)) ** Progress reports**

((I)) ** In general** Not later than 18 months after , the Administrator, in coordination with the head of each other covered agency, shall submit to the Committee on Agriculture of the House of Representatives and the Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry of the Senate a report describing the progress of the working group in developing the recommendations under subparagraph (B).December 20, 20182018-12-20

((II)) ** Requirements** The report under this clause shall—

((aa)) reflect the perspectives of each covered agency; and

((bb)) identify areas of new consensus and continuing topics of disagreement and debate.

((ii)) ** Results**

((I)) ** In general** Not later than 1 year after , the Administrator, in coordination with the head of each other covered agency, shall submit to the Committee on Agriculture of the House of Representatives and the Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry of the Senate a report describing—

((aa)) the recommendations developed under subparagraph (B); and

((bb)) plans for implementation of those recommendations.

((II)) ** Requirements** The report under this clause shall—

((aa)) reflect the perspectives of each covered agency; and

((bb)) identify areas of consensus and continuing topics of disagreement and debate, if any.

((iii)) ** Implementation** Not later than 1 year after the date of submission of the report under clause (i), the Administrator, in coordination with the head of each other covered agency, shall submit to the Committee on Agriculture of the House of Representatives and the Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry of the Senate a report describing—

((I)) the implementation of the recommendations referred to in that clause;

((II)) the extent to which that implementation improved the consultation process referred to in subparagraph (B); and

((III)) any additional recommendations for improvements to the process described in subparagraph (B).

((iv)) ** Other reports** Not later than the date that is 180 days after the date of submission of the report under clause (iii), and not less frequently than once every 180 days thereafter during the 5-year period beginning on that date, the Administrator, in coordination with the head of each other covered agency, shall submit to the Committee on Agriculture of the House of Representatives and the Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry of the Senate a report describing—

((I)) the implementation of the recommendations referred to in that clause;

((II)) the extent to which that implementation improved the consultation process referred to in subparagraph (B); and

((III)) any additional recommendations for improvements to the process described in subparagraph (B).

((E)) ** Consultation with private sector** In carrying out the duties under this paragraph, the working group shall, as appropriate—

((i)) consult with, representatives of interested industry stakeholders and nongovernmental organizations; and

((ii)) take into consideration factors, such as actual and potential differences in interest between, and the views of, those stakeholders and organizations.

((F)) ** Chapter 10 of title 5** Chapter 10 of title 5 shall not apply to the working group established under this paragraph.

((G)) ** Savings clause** Nothing in this paragraph supersedes any provision of—

((i)) this subchapter; or

((ii)) the Endangered Species Act of 1973 ( et seq.), including the requirements under section 7 of that Act ().

((d)) ** Classification of pesticides**

((1)) ** Classification for general use, restricted use, or both**

((A)) As a part of the registration of a pesticide the Administrator shall classify it as being for general use or for restricted use. If the Administrator determines that some of the uses for which the pesticide is registered should be for general use and that other uses for which it is registered should be for restricted use, the Administrator shall classify it for both general use and restricted use. Pesticide uses may be classified by regulation on the initial classification, and registered pesticides may be classified prior to reregistration. If some of the uses of the pesticide are classified for general use, and other uses are classified for restricted use, the directions relating to its general uses shall be clearly separated and distinguished from those directions relating to its restricted uses. The Administrator may require that its packaging and labeling for restricted uses shall be clearly distinguishable from its packaging and labeling for general uses.

((B)) If the Administrator determines that the pesticide, when applied in accordance with its directions for use, warnings and cautions and for the uses for which it is registered, or for one or more of such uses, or in accordance with a widespread and commonly recognized practice, will not generally cause unreasonable adverse effects on the environment, the Administrator will classify the pesticide, or the particular use or uses of the pesticide to which the determination applies, for general use.

((C)) If the Administrator determines that the pesticide, when applied in accordance with its directions for use, warnings and cautions and for the uses for which it is registered, or for one or more of such uses, or in accordance with a widespread and commonly recognized practice, may generally cause, without additional regulatory restrictions, unreasonable adverse effects on the environment, including injury to the applicator, the Administrator shall classify the pesticide, or the particular use or uses to which the determination applies, for restricted use:

((i)) If the Administrator classifies a pesticide, or one or more uses of such pesticide, for restricted use because of a determination that the acute dermal or inhalation toxicity of the pesticide presents a hazard to the applicator or other persons, the pesticide shall be applied for any use to which the restricted classification applies only by or under the direct supervision of a certified applicator.

((ii)) If the Administrator classifies a pesticide, or one or more uses of such pesticide, for restricted use because of a determination that its use without additional regulatory restriction may cause unreasonable adverse effects on the environment, the pesticide shall be applied for any use to which the determination applies only by or under the direct supervision of a certified applicator, or subject to such other restrictions as the Administrator may provide by regulation. Any such regulation shall be reviewable in the appropriate court of appeals upon petition of a person adversely affected filed within 60 days of the publication of the regulation in final form.

((2)) ** Change in classification** If the Administrator determines that a change in the classification of any use of a pesticide from general use to restricted use is necessary to prevent unreasonable adverse effects on the environment, the Administrator shall notify the registrant of such pesticide of such determination at least forty-five days before making the change and shall publish the proposed change in the Federal Register. The registrant, or other interested person with the concurrence of the registrant, may seek relief from such determination under .section 136d(b) of this title

((3)) ** Change in classification from restricted use to general use** The registrant of any pesticide with one or more uses classified for restricted use may petition the Administrator to change any such classification from restricted to general use. Such petition shall set out the basis for the registrant’s position that restricted use classification is unnecessary because classification of the pesticide for general use would not cause unreasonable adverse effects on the environment. The Administrator, within sixty days after receiving such petition, shall notify the registrant whether the petition has been granted or denied. Any denial shall contain an explanation therefor and any such denial shall be subject to judicial review under .section 136n of this title

((e)) ** Products with same formulation and claims** Products which have the same formulation, are manufactured by the same person, the labeling of which contains the same claims, and the labels of which bear a designation identifying the product as the same pesticide may be registered as a single pesticide; and additional names and labels shall be added to the registration by supplemental statements.

((f)) ** Miscellaneous**

((1)) ** Effect of change of labeling or formulation** If the labeling or formulation for a pesticide is changed, the registration shall be amended to reflect such change if the Administrator determines that the change will not violate any provision of this subchapter.

((2)) ** Registration not a defense** In no event shall registration of an article be construed as a defense for the commission of any offense under this subchapter. As long as no cancellation proceedings are in effect registration of a pesticide shall be prima facie evidence that the pesticide, its labeling and packaging comply with the registration provisions of the subchapter.

((3)) ** Authority to consult other Federal agencies** In connection with consideration of any registration or application for registration under this section, the Administrator may consult with any other Federal agency.

((4)) ** Mixtures of nitrogen stabilizers and fertilizer products** Any mixture or other combination of—

((A)) 1 or more nitrogen stabilizers registered under this subchapter; and

((B)) 1 or more fertilizer products,

((5)) ** Bilingual labeling**

((A)) ** Requirement**

((i)) ** In general** Subject to clause (ii), not later than the applicable deadline described in subparagraph (B), each registered pesticide product released for shipment shall include—

((I)) the translation of the parts of the labeling contained in the Spanish Translation Guide described in subparagraph (G) on the product container; or

((II)) a link to such translation via scannable technology or other electronic methods readily accessible on the product label.

((ii)) ** Exceptions** Notwithstanding clause (i)—

((I)) an antimicrobial pesticide product may, in lieu of including a translation or a link under clause (i), provide a link to the safety data sheets in Spanish via scannable technology or other electronic methods readily accessible on the product label; or

((II)) a non-agricultural pesticide product that is not classified by the Administrator as restricted use under subsection (d)(1)(A) may, in lieu of including a translation or a link under clause (i), provide a link to the safety data sheets in Spanish via scannable technology or other electronic methods readily accessible on the product label.

((B)) ** Deadlines for bilingual labeling**

((i)) ** Pesticide products classified as restricted use** In the case of pesticide products classified by the Administrator as restricted use under subsection (d)(1)(A), the deadline specified in this subparagraph is the date that is 3 years following .December 29, 20222022-12-29

((ii)) ** Pesticide products not classified as restricted use** In the case of pesticide products not classified by the Administrator as restricted use under subsection (d)(1)(A), the deadline specified in this subparagraph shall be as follows:

((I)) ** Agricultural**

((aa)) ** Acute Toxicity Category I** For agricultural pesticides classified as Acute Toxicity Category I, the date that is 3 years after .December 29, 20222022-12-29

((bb)) ** Acute Toxicity Category II** For agricultural pesticides classified as Acute Toxicity Category II, the date that is 5 years after .December 29, 20222022-12-29

((II)) ** Antimicrobial and non-agricultural**

((aa)) ** Acute Toxicity Category I** For antimicrobial and non-agricultural pesticide products classified as Acute Toxicity Category I, the date that is 4 years after .December 29, 20222022-12-29

((bb)) ** Acute Toxicity Category II** For antimicrobial and non-agricultural pesticide products classified as Acute Toxicity Category II, the date that is 6 years after .December 29, 20222022-12-29

((III)) ** Other pesticide products** With respect to pesticide products not described in subclause (I) or (II), the date that is 8 years after .December 29, 20222022-12-29

((C)) ** Implementation**

((i)) ** Non-notification**

((I)) ** In general** In carrying out this paragraph, the Administrator shall allow translations of the parts of the label of a pesticide contained in the Spanish Translation Guide described in subparagraph (G) and scannable technology or other electronic methods to be added using non-notification procedures.

((II)) ** Non-notification procedure defined** In this clause, the term “non-notification procedure” refers to a procedure under which a change may be made to a pesticide label without notifying the Administrator.

((ii)) ** Cooperation and consultation** In carrying out this paragraph, the Administrator shall cooperate and consult with State lead agencies for pesticide regulation for the purpose of implementing bilingual labeling as provided in this paragraph as expeditiously as possible.

((iii)) ** End use labeling** The labeling requirements of this paragraph shall apply to end use product labels.

((iv)) ** Incorporation timeframe** After initial translation deadlines provided in subparagraph (B), updates to the Spanish Translation Guide described in subparagraph (G) shall be incorporated into labeling on the earlier of—

((I)) in the case of agricultural use pesticide labels, as determined by the Administrator—

((aa)) 1 year after the date of publication of the updated Spanish Label Translation Guide described in subparagraph (G); or

((bb)) the released for shipment date specified on the EPA Stamped Approved Label after the pesticide label is next changed or amended following the date of publication of the updated Spanish Label Translation Guide described in subparagraph (G); and

((II)) in the case of antimicrobial and non-agricultural use pesticide labels, as determined by the Administrator—

((aa)) 2 years after the date of publication of the updated Spanish Label Translation Guide described in subparagraph (G); or

((bb)) the released for shipment date specified on the EPA Stamped Approved Label after the pesticide label is next changed or amended following the date of publication of the updated Spanish Label Translation Guide described in subparagraph (G).

((v)) ** Notification of updates to the Spanish Translation Guide for Pesticide Labeling** Not later than 10 days after updating the Spanish Translation Guide described in subparagraph (G), the Administrator shall notify registrants of the update to such guide.

((D)) ** Accessibility of bilingual labeling for farm workers** Not later than 180 days after , to the maximum extent practicable, the Administrator shall seek stakeholder input on ways to make bilingual labeling required under this paragraph accessible to farm workers.December 29, 20222022-12-29

((E)) ** Plan** Not later than 3 years after , the Administrator shall implement a plan to ensure that farm workers have access to the bilingual labeling required under this paragraph.December 29, 20222022-12-29

((F)) ** Reporting** Not later than 2 years after , the Administrator shall develop and implement, and make publicly available, a plan for tracking the adoption of the bilingual labeling required under this paragraph.December 29, 20222022-12-29

((G)) ** Spanish Translation Guide described** The Spanish Translation Guide described in this subparagraph is the Spanish Translation Guide for Pesticide Labeling issued in October 2019, as in effect on , and any successor guides or amendments to such guide.December 29, 20222022-12-29

((g)) ** Registration review**

((1)) ** General rule**

((A)) ** Periodic review**

((i)) ** In general** The registrations of pesticides are to be periodically reviewed.

((ii)) ** Regulations** In accordance with this subparagraph, the Administrator shall by regulation establish a procedure for accomplishing the periodic review of registrations.

((iii)) ** Initial registration review** The Administrator shall complete the registration review of each pesticide or pesticide case, which may be composed of 1 or more active ingredients and the products associated with the active ingredients, not later than the later of—

((I)) ; or

((II)) the date that is 15 years after the date on which the first pesticide containing a new active ingredient is registered.

((iv)) ** Subsequent registration review** Not later than 15 years after the date on which the initial registration review is completed under clause (iii) and each 15 years thereafter, the Administrator shall complete a subsequent registration review for each pesticide or pesticide case.

((v)) ** Cancellation** No registration shall be canceled as a result of the registration review process unless the Administrator follows the procedures and substantive requirements of .section 136d of this title

((B)) ** Docketing**

((i)) ** In general** Subject to clause (ii), after meeting with 1 or more individuals that are not government employees to discuss matters relating to a registration review, the Administrator shall place in the docket minutes of the meeting, a list of attendees, and any documents exchanged at the meeting, not later than the earlier of—

((I)) the date that is 45 days after the meeting; or

((II)) the date of issuance of the registration review decision.

((ii)) ** Protected information** The Administrator shall identify, but not include in the docket, any confidential business information the disclosure of which is prohibited by .section 136h of this title

((C)) ** Limitation** Nothing in this subsection shall prohibit the Administrator from undertaking any other review of a pesticide pursuant to this subchapter.

((2)) ** Data**

((A)) ** Submission required** The Administrator shall use the authority in subsection (c)(2)(B) to require the submission of data when such data are necessary for a registration review.

((B)) ** Data submission, compensation, and exemption** For purposes of this subsection, the provisions of subsections (c)(1), (c)(2)(B), and (c)(2)(D) shall be utilized for and be applicable to any data required for registration review.

((h)) ** Registration requirements for antimicrobial pesticides**

((1)) ** Evaluation of process** To the maximum extent practicable consistent with the degrees of risk presented by an antimicrobial pesticide and the type of review appropriate to evaluate the risks, the Administrator shall identify and evaluate reforms to the antimicrobial registration process that would reduce review periods existing as of , for antimicrobial pesticide product registration applications and applications for amended registration of antimicrobial pesticide products, including—

((A)) new antimicrobial active ingredients;

((B)) new antimicrobial end-use products;

((C)) substantially similar or identical antimicrobial pesticides; and

((D)) amendments to antimicrobial pesticide registrations.

((2)) ** Review time period reduction goal** Each reform identified under paragraph (1) shall be designed to achieve the goal of reducing the review period following submission of a complete application, consistent with the degree of risk, to a period of not more than—

((A)) 540 days for a new antimicrobial active ingredient pesticide registration;

((B)) 270 days for a new antimicrobial use of a registered active ingredient;

((C)) 120 days for any other new antimicrobial product;

((D)) 90 days for a substantially similar or identical antimicrobial product;

((E)) 90 days for an amendment to an antimicrobial registration that does not require scientific review of data; and

((F)) 120 days for an amendment to an antimicrobial registration that requires scientific review of data and that is not otherwise described in this paragraph.

((3)) ** Implementation**

((A)) ** Proposed rulemaking**

((i)) ** Issuance** Not later than 270 days after , the Administrator shall publish in the Federal Register proposed regulations to accelerate and improve the review of antimicrobial pesticide products designed to implement, to the extent practicable, the goals set forth in paragraph (2).August 3, 19961996-08-03

((ii)) ** Requirements** Proposed regulations issued under clause (i) shall—

((I)) define the various classes of antimicrobial use patterns, including household, industrial, and institutional disinfectants and sanitizing pesticides, preservatives, water treatment, and pulp and paper mill additives, and other such products intended to disinfect, sanitize, reduce, or mitigate growth or development of microbiological organisms, or protect inanimate objects, industrial processes or systems, surfaces, water, or other chemical substances from contamination, fouling, or deterioration caused by bacteria, viruses, fungi, protozoa, algae, or slime;

((II)) differentiate the types of review undertaken for antimicrobial pesticides;

((III)) conform the degree and type of review to the risks and benefits presented by antimicrobial pesticides and the function of review under this subchapter, considering the use patterns of the product, toxicity, expected exposure, and product type;

((IV)) ensure that the registration process is sufficient to maintain antimicrobial pesticide efficacy and that antimicrobial pesticide products continue to meet product performance standards and effectiveness levels for each type of label claim made; and

((V)) implement effective and reliable deadlines for process management.

((iii)) ** Comments** In developing the proposed regulations, the Administrator shall solicit the views from registrants and other affected parties to maximize the effectiveness of the rule development process.

((B)) ** Final regulations**

((i)) ** Issuance** The Administrator shall issue final regulations not later than 240 days after the close of the comment period for the proposed regulations.

((ii)) ** Failure to meet goal** If a goal described in paragraph (2) is not met by the final regulations, the Administrator shall identify the goal, explain why the goal was not attained, describe the element of the regulations included instead, and identify future steps to attain the goal.

((iii)) ** Requirements** In issuing final regulations, the Administrator shall—

((I)) consider the establishment of a certification process for regulatory actions involving risks that can be responsibly managed, consistent with the degree of risk, in the most cost-efficient manner;

((II)) consider the establishment of a certification process by approved laboratories as an adjunct to the review process;

((III)) use all appropriate and cost-effective review mechanisms, including—

((aa)) expanded use of notification and non-notification procedures;

((bb)) revised procedures for application review; and

((cc)) allocation of appropriate resources to ensure streamlined management of antimicrobial pesticide registrations; and

((IV)) clarify criteria for determination of the completeness of an application.

((C)) ** Expedited review** This subsection does not affect the requirements or extend the deadlines or review periods contained in subsection (c)(3).

((D)) ** Alternative review periods** If the final regulations to carry out this paragraph are not effective 630 days after , until the final regulations become effective, the review period, beginning on the date of receipt by the Agency of a complete application, shall be—

((i)) 2 years for a new antimicrobial active ingredient pesticide registration;

((ii)) 1 year for a new antimicrobial use of a registered active ingredient;

((iii)) 180 days for any other new antimicrobial product;

((iv)) 90 days for a substantially similar or identical antimicrobial product;

((v)) 90 days for an amendment to an antimicrobial registration that does not require scientific review of data; and

((vi)) 120 days for an amendment to an antimicrobial registration that requires scientific review of data and that is not otherwise described in this subparagraph.

((E)) ** Wood preservatives** An application for the registration, or for an amendment to the registration, of a wood preservative product for which a claim of pesticidal activity listed in is made (regardless of any other pesticidal claim that is made with respect to the product) shall be reviewed by the Administrator within the same period as that established under this paragraph for an antimicrobial pesticide product application, consistent with the degree of risk posed by the use of the wood preservative product, if the application requires the applicant to satisfy the same data requirements as are required to support an application for a wood preservative product that is an antimicrobial pesticide.section 136(mm) of this title

((F)) ** Notification**

((i)) ** In general** Subject to clause (iii), the Administrator shall notify an applicant whether an application has been granted or denied not later than the final day of the appropriate review period under this paragraph, unless the applicant and the Administrator agree to a later date.

((ii)) ** Final decision** If the Administrator fails to notify an applicant within the period of time required under clause (i), the failure shall be considered an agency action unlawfully withheld or unreasonably delayed for purposes of judicial review under chapter 7 of title 5.

((iii)) ** Exemption** This subparagraph does not apply to an application for an antimicrobial pesticide that is filed under subsection (c)(3)(B) prior to 90 days after .August 3, 19961996-08-03

((iv)) ** Limitation** Notwithstanding clause (ii), the failure of the Administrator to notify an applicant for an amendment to a registration for an antimicrobial pesticide shall not be judicially reviewable in a Federal or State court if the amendment requires scientific review of data within—

((I)) the time period specified in subparagraph (D)(vi), in the absence of a final regulation under subparagraph (B); or

((II)) the time period specified in paragraph (2)(F), if adopted in a final regulation under subparagraph (B).

((4)) ** Annual report**

((A)) ** Submission** Beginning on , and ending on the date that the goals under paragraph (2) are achieved, the Administrator shall, not later than March 1 of each year, prepare and submit an annual report to the Committee on Agriculture of the House of Representatives and the Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry of the Senate.August 3, 19961996-08-03

((B)) ** Requirements** A report submitted under subparagraph (A) shall include a description of—

((i)) measures taken to reduce the backlog of pending registration applications;

((ii)) progress toward achieving reforms under this subsection; and

((iii)) recommendations to improve the activities of the Agency pertaining to antimicrobial registrations.