Sponsors (7)
The bill strengthens DOE-related national security by restricting access for nationals of certain countries while allowing limited waivers and oversight, but it risks disrupting research, losing talent and expertise, raising discrimination and diplomatic concerns, and adding administrative burden.
Researchers and DOE/national lab staff face reduced risk of foreign intelligence theft or espionage because access by nationals of certain countries is restricted.
Scientists and research institutions can still pursue critical collaborations in exceptional cases because the Secretary of Energy can grant case‑by‑case waivers when benefits outweigh risks.
Congressional committees (and thus taxpayers) receive timely notification about any granted waivers (within 30 days), increasing transparency and oversight of exceptions.
Scientists and research partners from the listed countries will be barred from collaboration, disrupting ongoing projects and slowing research progress across universities and national labs.
U.S. universities and national labs may lose access to specialized talent and expertise, causing increased costs, reduced competitiveness, and delayed projects (costs borne by institutions and taxpayers).
The policy may be perceived as discriminatory toward nationals of certain countries, raising civil‑liberties and diplomatic concerns and potentially harming international scientific relationships.
Based on analysis of 2 sections of legislative text.
Bars nationals of China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, and Cuba from accessing DOE national labs as short-term visitors or longer-term assignees unless the Secretary issues a waiver.
Official title: Prohibit National Laboratories from admitting certain foreign nationals, and for other purposes.
Introduced March 11, 2025 by Thomas Bryant Cotton · Last progress March 11, 2025
Prohibits certain foreign nationals from China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, and Cuba from entering or accessing U.S. Department of Energy national laboratories as either short-term visitors (under 31 days) or longer-term assignees (over 30 consecutive days). The Secretary of Energy may grant a written waiver after consulting DOE counterintelligence and an FBI counterintelligence official if the national interest benefits outweigh security and economic risks, and must notify six congressional committees within 30 days with details on the waiver decision.